A moral choice by mary gordon essay

Example Argumentative Essay on Abortion Argumentative Essay Sample on Abortion I would like to first point out the fact that abortion is one of the most controversial issues in the United States. The progressive left stands strong on the argument that women deserve the sole right to decide on abortion. Whether your stance on abortion is pro or anti it is a legal operation in the United States. In the year abortion laws were decided by the states.

A moral choice by mary gordon essay

It should not be confused with miscarriage which involves no human intention or contraception which uses various technologies to prohibit sperm and egg from producing a fertilized ovum after sexual intercourse.

Miscarriages are natural if sad occurrences, which raise no deep moral issues regarding human conduct—unless the woman was careless in her pregnancy.

Contraception is officially opposed by Roman Catholics and some other Christians, but I take it to be in a moral category entirely separate from abortion since it does not involve the killing of a fetus ; therefore, it will not be addressed here.

Wadethis essay makes a simple, straightforward moral argument against abortion. Sadly, real arguments reasoned defenses of a thesis or claim are too rarely made on this issue. Instead, propaganda is exchanged. Given that the Obama administration is the most pro-abortion administration in the history of the United States, some clear moral reasoning is called for at this time.

The first premise of the argument is that human beings have unique and incomparable value in the world. Christians and Jews believe this is the case because we are made in God's image and likeness.

But anyone who holds that humans are special and worthy of unique moral consideration can grant this thesis even if their worldview does not ultimately support it. Of course, those like Peter Singer who do not grant humans any special status will not be moved by this.

Many true and justified beliefs concerning human beings and other matters are denied by otherwise intelligent people. Second, the burden of proof should always be on the one taking a human life and the benefit of doubt should always be given to the human life. This is not to say that human life should never be taken.

In an often cruel and unfair world, sometimes life-taking is necessary, as many people will grant. Cases include self-defense, the prosecution of a just war, and capital punishment.

Search This Blog

Yet all unnecessary and intentional life-taking is murder, a deeply evil and repugnant offense against human beings.

This would also be acknowledged by those, such as absolute pacifists, who believe that it is never justifiable to take a human life. Third, abortion nearly always takes a human life intentionally and gratuitously and is, therefore, morally unjustified, deeply evil, and repugnant—given what we have said about human beings.

The fetus is, without question, a human being. Biologically, an entity joins its parents' species at conception. If the fetus is not human, what else could it possibly be? Could it be an ape or a rabbit? Some philosophers, such as Mary Anne Warren, have tried to drive a wedge between personhood and humanity.

That is, there may be persons who are not human such as God, angels, ETs—if they existand there may be humans that are not persons fetuses or those who lose certain functions after having possessed them. While it is true that there may be persons who are not humans, it does not logically follow that there are humans who are not persons.

Contents | The Norton Reader | W. W. Norton & Company

The fetus is best regarded as a person with potential, not a potential person or nonperson. But what are these person-constituting qualities? Some say a basic level of consciousness; others assert viability outside the womb; still others say a sense of self-interest which probably does not obtain until after birth.

All of these criteria would take away humanity from those in comas or other physically compromised situations. Moreover, who are we to say just what qualities make for membership in the moral community of persons?

If we are wrong in our identification of what qualities are sufficient for personhood and we allow a person to be killed, we have allowed the wrongful killing of nothing less than a person.

Therefore, I argue that personhood should be viewed as a substance or essence that is given at conception. The fetus is not a lifeless mechanism that only becomes what it is after several parts are put together—as is the case with a watch or an automobile.

Rather, the fetus is a living human organism, whose future unfolds from within itself according to internal principles.

A moral choice by mary gordon essay

For example, the fertilized ovum contains a complete genetic code that is distinct from that of the mother or father. But this is not a mere inert blueprint which is separable from the building it describes ; this is a living blueprint that becomes what its human nature demands.

Yet even if one is not sure when personhood becomes a reality, one should err on the side of being conservative simply because so much is at stake. That is, if one aborts a fetus who is already a person, one commits a deep moral wrong by wrongfully killing an innocent human life.

Just as we do not shoot target practice when we are told there may be children playing behind the targets, we should not abortion fetuses if they may be persons with the right not to be killed.Feb 01,  · Mary Gordon's essay, A Moral Choice, has been the center of controversy for several years.

From most of the posts that I've read, it seems that its toss- and - turn. Argumentative Essay Sample on Abortion. is an unmoral reason to abort. I do not see abortion as a sin due to the good points Mary Gordon makes in “A Moral Choice.” The most important point she makes is stating, “The moral discussion of abortion centers on the issue of whether or not abortion is an act of murder.

r-bridal.comot. In Mary Gordon took a bus to Washington to protest the Vietnam War. Much has changed in 50 years—except her determination to keep fighting. Feb 28,  · Mary Gordon's new novel is immensely engaging fun, a delightful romp by an author distinguished for narratives of rigorous self-denial, harrowing disillusionment, and painful self-discovery.

Sep 20,  · A moral choice by mary gordon essay >>> click to continue Literature review of portfolio management essays Free process papers, essays, and research papers situation, the concept of analytical hierarchy process ahp .

We provide high quality essay writing services on a 24/7 basis. Original papers, fast turnaround and reasonable prices!

Call us toll-free at

A Moral Choice - Mary Gordon by Elizabeth Zalla on Prezi